As seen in March 2010 Architectural Digest
© Conde Nast
Classical Epiphany

Restoration Architecture by Marco Vidotto
Interior Design by Susan Schuyler Smith, ASID, of Spectrum Interior Design
Text by John Loring
Photography by Kim Sargent



In their serene detachment from the momenta of the modern world, Tuscany’s hill towns today maintain all that exquisite simplicity so beloved of Florence’s and Siena’s Renaissance masters, who regularly depicted them in the backgrounds of their paintings of the holy and the heroic.

Artists and designers have long been drawn to the tranquil beauty of these villages’ clean lines, plain geometrical forms and graceful proportions situated in hilly landscapes of vineyards and olive groves punctuated by cypress and live oak trees.

Indeed, between 1503 and 1506, Leonardo da Vinci painted the Mona Lisa, which likely was set at the Villa Vigna-maggio, in the Chianti region, some 20 miles south of Florence. In 2005 Vero Beach, Florida, designer Susan Schuyler Smith began the restoration of a historically significant property in Le Convertoie, only three kilometers away.

Le Convertoie was fortified around the turn of the 12th century to guard part of the route between Florence and Siena; and, like most such towns, its church and houses formed a central conglomerate with shared walls. In the late Renaissance, the fortifications of many small outposts were demolished, but Le Convertoie today probably looks little different from what Leonardo da Vinci would have seen 500 years ago.

The property that Smith’s clients purchased in 2000 included the village church and the attached apartment and its garden. The church, once dedicated to Saint Sylvester, had been deconsecrated. Abandoned in the 1950s, it was stripped of its religious art, with only its altars, confessionals and baptismal font left behind. The sacristy, which the previous owners used for storage, was filled with rusted, obsolete farm equipment, an old stove, wine and oil bottles and hunks of salt pork hung from the rafters to cure. The house and garden were not in much better repair.

Smith had already done the interiors for her clients’ homes in Florida and North Carolina; however, the prospect of restoring a historic property in Italy and dealing with the Soprintendenza per i Beni Architettonici (part of the strict Italian historic preservation institution) was a whole new adventure. Luckily, the owners saw the work of an architect in nearby Siena featured in a book they were studying on the restoration of Italian homes. They contacted the architect, Marco Vidotto, and learned that he was working on a commission to design an important new church. “His affinity for churches both old and new,” the wife says, “made him a natural choice for our project.”

Vidotto recalls, “It was a fascinating project, not simply from an architectural standpoint but also from a historical one. I took the approach that the work should be finished to the highest degree, much as it would be in the renovation of an important church in Siena or Florence. We made this remarkable effort to restore the building to its original state—not because the Soprintendenza required that, but because it was important to the owners and to me that it be done that way.”

In July 2005 work on the chapel began. Before replastering, walls were stripped down to the galestro, a marl unique to the Chianti region. The unstable roof was removed and rebuilt. An unforeseen construction peculiarity caused the vault above the main altar to collapse in the process. A new vault was built. As the outworn floor was being removed to make way for underfloor heating and wiring, a large central cruciform section was discovered to contain the church crypts. They were left undisturbed, and heating and wiring were routed around them. The remaining floor was then resurfaced with handmade cotto pavers, from the Viterbo area of Italy, chosen for their pale rose shade that matched the color of the original flooring. The two side altars of dark pietra serena were cleaned and restored. The two confessionals were resurfaced and repainted their original darkest green.

Although the interior was undoubtedly once well populated with religious paintings and sculptures, “artwork was kept to a minimum,” Smith observes, “to emphasize the architecture of the church.” A 15th-century wooden statue of a saint occupies the niche above one altar, which is appropriately furnished with two tall candleholders. Above the facing altar there is a 16th-century Florentine painting of the presentation of Christ, whose architectural background of receding Renaissance arches complements the architecture of the church now gracefully transformed into the central living room of the house.

Restful colors and the lavish use of lighting play no small part in the great success of the interior. “Exacting measures were taken to ensure the authenticity of the colors used in the renovation,” the designer explains. “We were not only respectful of colors used in the original building but matched them perfectly with samples from the original walls.”

“If one thing comes to mind when I think of this project, it’s integrity,” she concludes. “Part of the beauty of the building is its history, and by incorporating that into the design of the renovation, it took the project to the next level and maintained the dignity of this timeless property.”

“It was a fascinating project, not simply from an architectural standpoint but also from a historical one.”


A proverb quotes that in Chianti, you can either stumble on a rock or upon a fool. Kyle's fate was to stumble upon a property named Le Convertoie.
"Altared" is a heartfelt chronicle about the author's unforeseen connection to a crumbling church and apartment that abruptly sidle into her life. It's not the typical cozy country home cast in a manicured garden and a pool to relax around idly. All the same, she tenaciously decides to pursue the endeavor and decides that must be the place. While the narrative unfolds, Kyle turns her existence upside down as she uncannily gets bonded to the ancient estate she lovingly converts into her Tuscan dream retreat. 
"Altared" is not just the life creation of an idea; it's also a tongue in cheek collection of some of the zaniest local characters, their tics, attitudes, ways, and weaknesses. It's a witty report on how the author respectfully approaches a sophisticated culture whose roots are deeply planted in an astonishingly glorious past, and that seems to be perilously hanging on to the present.
 - New York Times Bestselling Author,
Dario Castagno
Most people would have given up before even starting such a challenging renovation, but Kyle Ball’s passion and perseverance can only be admired. So many restorations and renovations of Italy’s rich cultural heritage were carried out in the last two centuries given the dedication and financial support of many non-Italians, and Kyle is the perfect example. Thanks to the fact that she shared her efforts with us in her book Altared, allows us to understand the importance and complexity of rediscovering this medieval church.  Her experience, though often rewarding, was also undoubtedly frustrating at times, but she tells the story with a sense of humor that endears us both to the writer and to her accomplishment.
 - Maurizio Seracini, art diagnostician based in Florence, Italy; founder of Editech; TED talk presenter on “The Secret Lives of Paintings;” mentioned in Dan Brown’s “The Da Vinci Code."
What a great job you did, Kyle! I laughed a lot (at the right parts, of course!) and you did a master’s job in relaying the ups and downs of buying abroad and renovating an historical building. I loved it!  I read it in about two days. It has always been my dream to write a book but I never had the attention span so I know what it took to do this project.
 - E. Watkins

© Copyright by Kyle Tackwell Ball 

Website design by